Skip to main content

AC Repair vs. AC Replacement: How to Make the Right Decision

June 6, 2025
Modified on June 4, 2025

The last thing you want to face after a wonderful day at Briar Bush Nature Center is a broken air conditioner. If you live in Abington, PA, or the surrounding areas, knowing when you might need an AC repair vs. an AC replacement is important. Several factors go into making such a decision, and the professionals at Chud Cooling and Heating provide a range of expert services, including air conditioner repair near you, full home comfort system replacements, and more to keep your home comfortable all summer.

hvac maintenance

Factors To Consider: AC Repair vs. Replacement

While there are plenty of benefits of a new air conditioner, there are also many factors to consider when deciding between a repair and a replacement. Keep these considerations in mind to help you decide which option might be best for you:

Cost and Budget

In most cases, the full HVAC replacement cost will be higher than the cost of a repair. However, if you’re paying for frequent repairs, it might make more financial sense to go ahead and pay for an upgrade. A good rule of thumb is that if you’re paying around 50 percent or more of the cost of a new AC on repairs, it’s probably better to go ahead and replace the system altogether.

Incentives for Upgrading

Some local, state, and federal incentives are available to homeowners who qualify when they upgrade to a new, energy-efficient air conditioner. These incentives may be in the form of manufacturer rebates, tax credits, and more. These extras may offset the cost of a new air conditioner enough to make the upgrade well worth the investment.

Comfort Issues

If your current AC is giving you problems and repeatedly performing poorly, replacing it makes more sense. There’s no need to suffer through the heat of summer when you can enjoy a reliable, consistent air conditioner. If your AC is not cooling your home and you’ve had it repaired before, it might be time to pay for an upgrade.

Signs It’s Time for AC Repair

Here are some signs you should call Chud Cooling and Heating for central air repair:

Uneven Cooling

You should schedule a repair if your AC starts blowing warm instead of cool air or if the airflow feels weak or uneven. This issue may be due to low refrigerant levels, a malfunctioning compressor, or a dirty air filter.

Odd Noises or Smells

Unusual sounds like screeching, hissing, banging, or clanking often indicate some form of internal damage that should be addressed. Musty or moldy smells may mean there’s a condensation issue, a leak, or a problem with the ductwork or air handler.

Operational Issues

An air conditioner that turns on and off frequently (short-cycling) or runs constantly without ever turning off is not working properly. This issue may be due to low refrigerant, airflow issues, dirty components, or a faulty thermostat.

ac installation

Signs It’s Time for AC Replacement

Sometimes, your air conditioner simply cannot (or should not) be repaired. Look for these signs that you need a new AC unit.

Rising Energy Bills

If your monthly energy bill suddenly spikes without a change in usage, it may be related to energy efficiency issues with your AC. This problem could be something simple, but it’s often a sign that your air conditioner is nearing the end of its lifespan.

Frequent Breakdowns

Dealing with frequent AC breakdowns is not only stressful — it’s also costing you money. If your AC consistently breaks down and you’re paying for repairs more than you normally would, it’s a good idea to consider a replacement.

Leaks

Any sign of water or refrigerant leaking, dripping, or pooling around your air conditioner is a serious red flag. Some leaks are fixable and could require emergency AC repair, but others may end up costing you more than it would to simply replace the AC.

Energy Efficiency and Long-Term Savings

Replacing your air conditioner results in better energy efficiency and provides long-term savings that your wallet will appreciate. Upgrading to a newer system means that your AC will have a higher SEER rating, so it will run much more efficiently and help you save on energy costs. When you replace your air conditioner, you’ll pay less — and likely nothing — for repairs for quite some time while enjoying lasting comfort and peace of mind. This not only translates into a more pleasant summer but also long-term savings since your new AC will be much more consistent and reliable to stand the test of time.

How Age Affects Your Decision

How long do air conditioners last? The average lifespan of most air conditioners is between 10 and 15 years if the system is well-maintained. If your AC is getting older and nearing the end of its lifespan, it’s usually much better to go ahead and replace it. Older air conditioners are much less energy efficient and more prone to breakdowns, and some models still use outdated refrigerants that are no longer available. Consider the age of your AC and use this as a factor when you make your decision.

When To Call the Pros at Chud Cooling & Heating

Here’s when to call Chud Cooling and Heating, the best HVAC company in Bucks County:

  • Odd smells, loud noises, or leaks are coming from your AC.
  • The AC is not turning on or cooling your home evenly.
  • Your energy bills are suddenly much higher than normal.
  • You’ve changed the air filter, but you still notice airflow issues.
  • Your air conditioner is short-cycling or stays on constantly.
  • You’d like to know whether repairing or replacing your AC makes more sense, and you need an assessment.

Chud vehicle

Contact Chud Today!

Don’t let a broken air conditioner ruin your summer. Chud Cooling and Heating is the go-to expert for all AC service needs in Bucks County and beyond. If you need air conditioner repair or want to learn more about getting a replacement, contact us today!

Request Service

Please fill out the form below to request an estimate or schedule service.

"*" indicates required fields

By clicking “Send Message”, I am providing express written consent to receive autodialed and pre-recorded calls, texts, and SMS/MMS with marketing communications from Chud Cooling and Heating regarding home services at the phone number provided above, even if the number is on a corporate, state, or national Do Not Call list. Consent is not a condition to purchase services or products.

Untitled*
This field is hidden when viewing the form
This field is hidden when viewing the form
This field is hidden when viewing the form
This field is hidden when viewing the form
This field is hidden when viewing the form
This field is hidden when viewing the form
This field is hidden when viewing the form
This field is hidden when viewing the form
This field is hidden when viewing the form
This field is hidden when viewing the form
This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
Customer Testimonials

Check Out Our 5-Star Reviews!


  • “I had a great experience with Chud. Lewis and Sebastian did a fantastic job. They were communicative and on time, explained everything that they would be doing to clean my HVAC ductwork, answered all of my questions, were honest about not being able to properly clean my dryer vent, and cleaned up after they were done. They also went above and beyond, even cleaning dust from each slat of the return vent. Highly recommend.”

    – Jay C.
  • “We have been a customer of Chud Air Conditioning, Heating & Duct Cleaning for many years and have always had a very satisfying experience. The technicians have been very responsive during emergencies, are informative, and professional. Shane was our recent service technician who replaced our water heater. Shane was excellent, very thorough, friendly, and dependable. I would not hesitate to use them again and don’t forget to ask for Shane!”

    – Michael M.
  • “We rely on Chud Duct Cleaning to perform our regular duct cleaning in our home. Your service technicians Lewis and Sebastian arrived promptly, introduced themselves and got right to work. Our home has many vents behind and under furniture, which was moved and replaced as if nothing ever happened. My home was carefully prepared and respected throughout the entire process. An access panel was replaced for a more pleasant look and better access in the future. I will not hesitate to use this company for service again.”

    – Catherine C.
  • “They came to service my heater and clean my ducts. They were super respectful of my property, thourough with their work, and carefully explained everything to me. My system is falling into disrepair. I could clearly see the rust and hear the problems they found. They recommended a variety of possible solutions from temporary furnace repairs to a new HVAC system. No pressure. I have a lot to think about, but it is good to know I have found someone I can trust to do the job.”

    – Phyllis W.
  • “Lewis and Sebastian were professional, knowledgeable and polite, and worked diligently over the course of two days to clean and sanitize the immense ductwork system at this location. They took the time to explain the process in detail, and were extremely aware of the need to treat a customer’s home as if it were their own. This was my second experience with Chud, and I won’t hesitate to call them again in the future.”

    – BC.
  • “Had a new heater and ac installed. Very pleased with entire process, from troubleshooting the old system to choosing the new to installation. Rich had patience with all my questions about the new system and helped me to understand the differences I should expect with the new. Matt and John did an outstanding job pulling out the old and installing the new. They got there on time and got right to work. Very professional technicians. Overall, a top notch job at a fair price. I highly recommend Chud.”

    – Phil W.

    Schedule Service

    "*" indicates required fields

    By clicking “Send Message”, I am providing express written consent to receive autodialed and pre-recorded calls, texts, and SMS/MMS with marketing communications from Chud Cooling and Heating regarding home services at the phone number provided above, even if the number is on a corporate, state, or national Do Not Call list. Consent is not a condition to purchase services or products.

    Untitled*
    This field is hidden when viewing the form
    This field is hidden when viewing the form
    This field is hidden when viewing the form
    This field is hidden when viewing the form
    This field is hidden when viewing the form
    This field is hidden when viewing the form
    This field is hidden when viewing the form
    This field is hidden when viewing the form
    This field is hidden when viewing the form
    This field is hidden when viewing the form
    This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.